Law Week Colorado
  • News
    • All Corporate Counsel Insight Features Legislature
      Features

      2019 Colorado 200 Ranking Colorado law office head…

      December 4, 2019

      Featured Stories

      The 6th District: An Outlier in Southwest Colorado…

      December 3, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Colorado Overtime Rule Would Trigger ‘Scramble’ Nearly 200,000…

      December 2, 2019

      Court Opinions

      Judge Timbreza Gets Suspension for DWAI 21st District…

      December 2, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Colorado Overtime Rule Would Trigger ‘Scramble’ Nearly 200,000…

      December 2, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      SEC Touts Enforcement Success Despite Shutdown Enforcement Division…

      November 27, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      ADA Claims Don’t Require Medical Experts, Panel Says…

      November 19, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Federal Circuit Breaks, Fixes PTAB Judges Scheme Despite…

      November 15, 2019

      Features

      2019 Colorado 200 Ranking Colorado law office head…

      December 4, 2019

      Features

      SCOTUS to Decide Case About Attorney Fees in…

      October 15, 2019

      Features

      SCOTUS to Decide on Fees in Patent Litigation…

      October 15, 2019

      Features

      Making His Mark: Activist Simon Tam Speaks in…

      October 14, 2019

      Legislature

      Will Cannabis Soon Get ‘SAFE’ Haven for Banking?…

      November 27, 2019

      Legislature

      Getting Reliable Data for Paid Leave Bill sponsor…

      November 26, 2019

      Legislature

      A Step Closer to Closing Pay Gaps CWBA…

      May 29, 2019

      Legislature

      Equal Pay Bill Clears First House Hearing Bill…

      April 22, 2019

  • Business
    • Business of Law

      New Lawyers: You’re Going to Get Good at…

      November 20, 2019

      Business of Law

      Merger Forms 400-Attorney Firm Lathrop Gage is merging…

      November 5, 2019

      Business of Law

      Holland & Hart Prepares Chair Changeover Newly elected…

      November 4, 2019

      Business of Law

      Major Lindsey & Africa to Open Denver Office…

      October 25, 2019

      Business of Law

      Major Lindsey & Africa to Open Denver Office…

      October 15, 2019

  • Courts
    • Courts

      Supreme Court: Medical Marijuana OK on Probation Colorado…

      November 26, 2019

      Courts

      Large-Capacity Magazine Ban Argued at High Court Attorneys…

      November 22, 2019

      Courts

      Defining Residential Land for Property Taxes Supreme Court’s…

      November 5, 2019

      Courts

      Denver Jury Awards $26.6M in Car Crash Case…

      October 11, 2019

      Courts

      Black Hawk Casino Expansion Marred by Contractor’s Lawsuit…

      October 11, 2019

  • People
    • All Associate Watch Lateral Watch
      In The Community

      Friends and Colleagues Remember Alli Gerkman IAALS senior…

      September 9, 2019

      Business of Law

      Silicon Flatirons Names New Executive Director Amie Stepanovich…

      July 15, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Fisher Phillips Expands Mining and Workplace Safety Practices…

      April 9, 2019

      Associate Watch

      Three Join Holland & Hart’s Tax and Benefits…

      March 20, 2019

      Associate Watch

      Three Join Holland & Hart’s Tax and Benefits…

      March 20, 2019

      Associate Watch

      Ballard Spahr Adds Two

      November 19, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Holland & Hart Adds Four Associates

      November 15, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Stinson Leonard Street Adds to Business Litigation Division

      November 13, 2018

      Lateral Watch

      Fisher Phillips Expands Mining and Workplace Safety Practices…

      April 9, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Brownstein Adds Shareholder to Litigation Department

      February 21, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Caplan & Earnest Adds One

      February 19, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Foley & Lardner Adds Health Care Partner

      November 27, 2018

  • Community
    • All Education Events
      Education

      College Course Offers Roadmap for Legal Marketing Industry…

      December 5, 2019

      Events

      This is Not a Memorial for Judge Richard…

      November 26, 2019

      Events

      ‘Ethics Revue’: A Night at the Cabaret The…

      November 18, 2019

      Featured Stories

      IAALS Report Studies Client Expectations Report builds on…

      November 13, 2019

      Education

      College Course Offers Roadmap for Legal Marketing Industry…

      December 5, 2019

      Education

      DU Law Students Lead New Venture Fund Student-run…

      September 27, 2019

      Education

      IAALS Announces Collaboration for New Research on Bar…

      August 14, 2019

      Education

      Silicon Flatirons Names New Executive Director Amie Stepanovich…

      July 15, 2019

      Events

      This is Not a Memorial for Judge Richard…

      November 26, 2019

      Events

      ‘Ethics Revue’: A Night at the Cabaret The…

      November 18, 2019

      Events

      Pros and Cons of National Injunctions CU Law…

      November 11, 2019

      Events

      Fixing the Federal Courts Advocacy group leader calls…

      November 4, 2019

  • Opinion
    • Opinion

      No Vacation From Legal Uncertainty Colorado’s conflicting directions…

      October 25, 2019

      Opinion

      Blockchain in the Fast Lane

      October 21, 2019

      Opinion

      A Deeper Dive Into FTC’s Record-Breaking Fine to…

      October 21, 2019

      Opinion

      SEC Calling: The Trouble With Finders in Connection…

      October 7, 2019

      Opinion

      Navigating the Minefield Laid by Prior Counsel’s Negligent…

      September 30, 2019

  • Hearsay
Law Week Colorado
  • News
    • All Corporate Counsel Insight Features Legislature
      Features

      2019 Colorado 200 Ranking Colorado law office head…

      December 4, 2019

      Featured Stories

      The 6th District: An Outlier in Southwest Colorado…

      December 3, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Colorado Overtime Rule Would Trigger ‘Scramble’ Nearly 200,000…

      December 2, 2019

      Court Opinions

      Judge Timbreza Gets Suspension for DWAI 21st District…

      December 2, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Colorado Overtime Rule Would Trigger ‘Scramble’ Nearly 200,000…

      December 2, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      SEC Touts Enforcement Success Despite Shutdown Enforcement Division…

      November 27, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      ADA Claims Don’t Require Medical Experts, Panel Says…

      November 19, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Federal Circuit Breaks, Fixes PTAB Judges Scheme Despite…

      November 15, 2019

      Features

      2019 Colorado 200 Ranking Colorado law office head…

      December 4, 2019

      Features

      SCOTUS to Decide Case About Attorney Fees in…

      October 15, 2019

      Features

      SCOTUS to Decide on Fees in Patent Litigation…

      October 15, 2019

      Features

      Making His Mark: Activist Simon Tam Speaks in…

      October 14, 2019

      Legislature

      Will Cannabis Soon Get ‘SAFE’ Haven for Banking?…

      November 27, 2019

      Legislature

      Getting Reliable Data for Paid Leave Bill sponsor…

      November 26, 2019

      Legislature

      A Step Closer to Closing Pay Gaps CWBA…

      May 29, 2019

      Legislature

      Equal Pay Bill Clears First House Hearing Bill…

      April 22, 2019

  • Business
    • Business of Law

      New Lawyers: You’re Going to Get Good at…

      November 20, 2019

      Business of Law

      Merger Forms 400-Attorney Firm Lathrop Gage is merging…

      November 5, 2019

      Business of Law

      Holland & Hart Prepares Chair Changeover Newly elected…

      November 4, 2019

      Business of Law

      Major Lindsey & Africa to Open Denver Office…

      October 25, 2019

      Business of Law

      Major Lindsey & Africa to Open Denver Office…

      October 15, 2019

  • Courts
    • Courts

      Supreme Court: Medical Marijuana OK on Probation Colorado…

      November 26, 2019

      Courts

      Large-Capacity Magazine Ban Argued at High Court Attorneys…

      November 22, 2019

      Courts

      Defining Residential Land for Property Taxes Supreme Court’s…

      November 5, 2019

      Courts

      Denver Jury Awards $26.6M in Car Crash Case…

      October 11, 2019

      Courts

      Black Hawk Casino Expansion Marred by Contractor’s Lawsuit…

      October 11, 2019

  • People
    • All Associate Watch Lateral Watch
      In The Community

      Friends and Colleagues Remember Alli Gerkman IAALS senior…

      September 9, 2019

      Business of Law

      Silicon Flatirons Names New Executive Director Amie Stepanovich…

      July 15, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Fisher Phillips Expands Mining and Workplace Safety Practices…

      April 9, 2019

      Associate Watch

      Three Join Holland & Hart’s Tax and Benefits…

      March 20, 2019

      Associate Watch

      Three Join Holland & Hart’s Tax and Benefits…

      March 20, 2019

      Associate Watch

      Ballard Spahr Adds Two

      November 19, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Holland & Hart Adds Four Associates

      November 15, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Stinson Leonard Street Adds to Business Litigation Division

      November 13, 2018

      Lateral Watch

      Fisher Phillips Expands Mining and Workplace Safety Practices…

      April 9, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Brownstein Adds Shareholder to Litigation Department

      February 21, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Caplan & Earnest Adds One

      February 19, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Foley & Lardner Adds Health Care Partner

      November 27, 2018

  • Community
    • All Education Events
      Education

      College Course Offers Roadmap for Legal Marketing Industry…

      December 5, 2019

      Events

      This is Not a Memorial for Judge Richard…

      November 26, 2019

      Events

      ‘Ethics Revue’: A Night at the Cabaret The…

      November 18, 2019

      Featured Stories

      IAALS Report Studies Client Expectations Report builds on…

      November 13, 2019

      Education

      College Course Offers Roadmap for Legal Marketing Industry…

      December 5, 2019

      Education

      DU Law Students Lead New Venture Fund Student-run…

      September 27, 2019

      Education

      IAALS Announces Collaboration for New Research on Bar…

      August 14, 2019

      Education

      Silicon Flatirons Names New Executive Director Amie Stepanovich…

      July 15, 2019

      Events

      This is Not a Memorial for Judge Richard…

      November 26, 2019

      Events

      ‘Ethics Revue’: A Night at the Cabaret The…

      November 18, 2019

      Events

      Pros and Cons of National Injunctions CU Law…

      November 11, 2019

      Events

      Fixing the Federal Courts Advocacy group leader calls…

      November 4, 2019

  • Opinion
    • Opinion

      No Vacation From Legal Uncertainty Colorado’s conflicting directions…

      October 25, 2019

      Opinion

      Blockchain in the Fast Lane

      October 21, 2019

      Opinion

      A Deeper Dive Into FTC’s Record-Breaking Fine to…

      October 21, 2019

      Opinion

      SEC Calling: The Trouble With Finders in Connection…

      October 7, 2019

      Opinion

      Navigating the Minefield Laid by Prior Counsel’s Negligent…

      September 30, 2019

  • Hearsay
Court OpinionsFeatured StoriesIn The CourtsNews

CO Supreme Court Releases Open Meetings Law Decision
The court ruled in favor of department of public health and environment

by Julia Cardi November 12, 2019
written by Julia Cardi November 12, 2019
CO Supreme Court Releases Open Meetings Law Decision The court ruled in favor of department of public health and environment

The Colorado Supreme Court released a batch of decisions Tuesday about the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, and among them decided an entire agency can’t be a “state public body” according to Colorado’s Open Meetings Law. The holding addresses a dispute over a specific CDPHE policy about referring physicians for investigation by the Colorado Medical Board based on their patterns of certifying patients for medical marijuana, which a group of unnamed physicians claimed violated the sunshine law and Administrative Procedure Act.

In two related opinions, the Supreme Court addressed claims from two physicians that subpoenas issued to investigate their practices under the policy didn’t have lawful purposes because they arose from an illegally adopted policy. Two Court of Appeals panels previously came to opposite decisions.

Justice Richard Gabriel wrote all three opinions. The main case, Doe v. Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, also decided the policy isn’t subject to the APA’s rule making requirements, and the referrals of the physicians aren’t subject to judicial review under the APA.

“…We conclude that the CDPHE, as a state agency, is not a ‘state public body’ under the OML, and therefore the Doctors have not established that the CDPHE violated the OML when it adopted the Referral Policy,” Gabriel wrote.

Running through all three cases is a policy the CDPHE implemented in order to have criteria for referring physicians to the Colorado Medical Board for investigation, prompted by a group of physicians who had unusually high rates of certifying patients for medical marijuana. The department adopted the policy without any public meetings or hearings.

The Denver District Court agreed with the physician John Does that the policymaking process violated the Open Meetings Law and granted their summary judgment motion to find the policy void. But the Court of Appeals ultimately overturned the district court in the John Does’ case. The panel reversed the summary judgment decision, finding the CDPHE isn’t a “state public body” subject to the Open Meetings Law.

And in the pair of cases against the Colorado Medical Board, physicians James Boland and Scott McLaughlin said subpoenas issued by the board to investigate their practices as a result of referrals from the CDPHE under the policy should be void because the policy was adopted illegally.

Two Court of Appeals panels made opposite decisions, and released them the same day on March 22, 2018, while the John Does’ case was still pending in the Court of Appeals. One agreed with McLaughlin and reversed the Denver District Court’s enforcement of the subpoena. The other panel sided with the Colorado Medical Board, and upheld enforcement of the subpoena for Boland’s records. So the Supreme Court reversed the decision in favor of McLaughlin and uphold the court’s decision in Boland’s case.

Based on the findings in the main case that the CDPHE didn’t violate the OML or APA when it adopted its policy, the Supreme Court found in favor of the Colorado Medical Board in the two companion cases.

“For this reason alone, we necessarily reject Scott McLaughlin’s argument that the investigative subpoena lacked a lawfully authorized purpose because it was based on a policy that violated the OML and the APA,” Gabriel wrote in Colorado Medical Board v. McLaughlin. “Even if the CDPHE’s adoption of the policy at issue and its reliance on it were invalid, however, we still would conclude that the Board’s investigative subpoena had a lawfully authorized purpose because it was issued pursuant to the Board’s statutory authority to investigate allegations of unprofessional conduct and was properly tailored to that purpose.”

The language of the Open Meetings Law covers meetings between two or more members of any “state public body” at which they discuss public business or may take formal action. In turn, the law’s definition of a state public body includes “any board, committee, commission, or other advisory, policy-making, rule-making, decision-making, or formally constituted body of any state agency.”

This language is where the Supreme Court jumps into the minute analysis of specific statutory words and phrases that is the signature of appellate courts. The phrase “of any state agency,” Gabriel wrote,” modifies the specific types of bodies that come right before the phrase. He reasoned if the definition did not include the “of any state agency” language, “the provision would define ‘state public body’ to include any board, committee, or commission regardless of whether these bodies had any connection to the state,” he wrote.

Doe v. CDPHE presented something of a mismatch between the question the Supreme Court agreed to hear and the issue at the heart of the case. The court granted cert on whether the CDPHE is a “state public body” subject to the Open Meetings Law, but that framing seems to imply the law would either apply or not apply to the department as a whole.

But the John Doe physicians didn’t argue the Open Meetings Law should apply to anything that happens at the CDPHE, such as employees discussing developments among themselves outside a formal setting. At the heart of the dispute is a whether the CDPHE’s process for adopting the specific policy violated the Open Meetings Law and Administrative Procedure Act.

 

Colorado Supreme Courtopen meetings law
0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
previous post
Legal Lasso: Supreme Court Hears DACA Arguments
next post
Budget Requests Indicate New Bail Reform Efforts Coming

Reprints

If you would like to order a reprint of this article, fill out the request form below and we will be in touch soon. If you prefer a phone call, please include your number.





  • Submit an Article
  • Submit a Verdict
  • Submit an Event to Law Week
  • Take a Survey
  • State Bill Info
  • Subscribe to Print Edition
  • Buy Copies/Reprints
  • Subscribe to Legal Lasso eNews
  • Gold Book Legislative Guide
  • Careers and Internships
  • Advertise
  • About Law Week
  • 2019 Editorial Calendar
  • Hearsay
  • Circuit Media
  • Locus Studios
  • Awards

  • Subscribe to Print Edition
  • Buy Copies/Reprints
  • Subscribe to Legal Lasso eNews
  • Gold Book Legislative Guide
  • Careers and Internships
  • Advertise

About Us

Published by Circuit Media, Law Week Colorado is the state’s only newspaper published specifically for lawyers, law firms, corporate counsel and the judiciary.

  • Submit an Article
  • Submit a Verdict
  • Submit an Event to Law Week
  • Take a Survey
  • State Bill Info

Follow Us

Facebook

© 2018 Law Week Colorado. All rights reserved.


Back To Top