Law Week Colorado
  • News
    • All Corporate Counsel Insight Features Legislature
      News

      Ballard Spahr Advises Telecommunications Company in Wireless Towers…

      February 21, 2019

      Legislature

      Senate Committee Advances Pay Equity Bill

      February 21, 2019

      Legislature

      Sen. Lee Hopes Bill for Court Appearance Reminders…

      February 19, 2019

      Legislature

      House Committee Advances Bill Expanding Sexual Contact Definition…

      February 18, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      ‘Equal Pay’ Bill Set for Hearing Senate Bill…

      February 18, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      OSHA Rescinds Controversial E-Reporting Requirements Agency also clears…

      February 14, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Helsinn SCOTUS Decision Ruling returns interpretation of on-sale…

      February 5, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      What GDPR Actions Against Google, Netflix Signal to…

      January 29, 2019

      Features

      Health Care Cost Controls Advance at the Capitol…

      February 13, 2019

      Features

      Sen. Winter Confident Paid Leave Bill Will Pass…

      February 13, 2019

      Features

      ‘Robot lawyers’ still coming, task efficiency should improve

      February 7, 2019

      Features

      The Business Case for Public Service Holland &…

      February 7, 2019

      Legislature

      Senate Committee Advances Pay Equity Bill

      February 21, 2019

      Legislature

      Sen. Lee Hopes Bill for Court Appearance Reminders…

      February 19, 2019

      Legislature

      House Committee Advances Bill Expanding Sexual Contact Definition…

      February 18, 2019

      Legislature

      Senate Judiciary Committee Kills Bill to Increase State…

      February 12, 2019

  • Business
    • Business of Law

      BCLP Launches Legal Operations Consultancy New focus provides…

      November 27, 2018

      Business of Law

      Lewis Roca Names New Colorado Managing Partner

      November 6, 2018

      Business of Law

      Lobbying Firms Under Microscope for Saudi Work

      November 5, 2018

      Business of Law

      Firmspace Targets Legal Profession

      November 2, 2018

      Business of Law

      Recruiter Salary Survey Finds Money Walks

      October 16, 2018

  • Courts
    • Courts

      10th Circuit Concludes Recreational Use Statute Case A…

      February 21, 2019

      Courts

      Pivotal Condemnation Case Argued at Colorado Supreme Court…

      February 19, 2019

      Courts

      Messner Reeves Sees Slew of Trial Wins

      February 14, 2019

      Courts

      Federal Appellate Court Considers ‘Right to Bail’ Eighth…

      January 31, 2019

      Courts

      Federal Appellate Court Considers ‘Right to Bail’

      January 31, 2019

  • People
    • All Associate Watch Lateral Watch
      Lateral Watch

      Brownstein Adds Shareholder to Litigation Department

      February 21, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Caplan & Earnest Adds One

      February 19, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Foley & Lardner Adds Health Care Partner

      November 27, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Ballard Spahr Adds Two

      November 19, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Ballard Spahr Adds Two

      November 19, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Holland & Hart Adds Four Associates

      November 15, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Stinson Leonard Street Adds to Business Litigation Division

      November 13, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Erise IP Adds Associate

      November 13, 2018

      Lateral Watch

      Brownstein Adds Shareholder to Litigation Department

      February 21, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Caplan & Earnest Adds One

      February 19, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Foley & Lardner Adds Health Care Partner

      November 27, 2018

      Lateral Watch

      Fred Yarger Rejoins Gibson Dunn

      November 12, 2018

  • Community
    • All Education Events
      Events

      Marijuana Regulators, Enforcers Deliver Insights Cannabis Symposium convenes…

      February 20, 2019

      Events

      Pledge to Diversity Kicks Off Law students mingle…

      February 6, 2019

      Events

      Hetal Doshi Receives Dick Davis Award Annual Dick…

      February 4, 2019

      In The Community

      Corporate Counsel Convene at Crawford Hotel ACC Colorado…

      January 30, 2019

      Education

      Beyond Just an Occupation

      November 12, 2018

      Education

      Pro Bono Week

      October 22, 2018

      Education

      CU Law Launches Human Rights Program

      December 11, 2017

      Education

      Setting the Bar on Law School Admissions

      November 15, 2017

      Events

      Marijuana Regulators, Enforcers Deliver Insights Cannabis Symposium convenes…

      February 20, 2019

      Events

      Pledge to Diversity Kicks Off Law students mingle…

      February 6, 2019

      Events

      Hetal Doshi Receives Dick Davis Award Annual Dick…

      February 4, 2019

      Events

      Ballard Spahr Attorneys Discuss Legal Risks of Public…

      December 7, 2018

  • Opinion
    • Opinion

      Millennials and the Practice of Law: A Changing…

      February 7, 2019

      Opinion

      When Cerebral Palsy is the Result of Medical…

      January 24, 2019

      Opinion

      Expecting the Unexpected

      November 23, 2018

      Opinion

      Surge in Apartment Construction Fuels Condo Conversions

      October 26, 2018

      Opinion

      Restrictive Covenants in Construction Contracts

      October 25, 2018

  • Hearsay

Law Week Colorado

  • News
    • All Corporate Counsel Insight Features Legislature
      News

      Ballard Spahr Advises Telecommunications Company in Wireless Towers…

      February 21, 2019

      Legislature

      Senate Committee Advances Pay Equity Bill

      February 21, 2019

      Legislature

      Sen. Lee Hopes Bill for Court Appearance Reminders…

      February 19, 2019

      Legislature

      House Committee Advances Bill Expanding Sexual Contact Definition…

      February 18, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      ‘Equal Pay’ Bill Set for Hearing Senate Bill…

      February 18, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      OSHA Rescinds Controversial E-Reporting Requirements Agency also clears…

      February 14, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      Helsinn SCOTUS Decision Ruling returns interpretation of on-sale…

      February 5, 2019

      Corporate Counsel Insight

      What GDPR Actions Against Google, Netflix Signal to…

      January 29, 2019

      Features

      Health Care Cost Controls Advance at the Capitol…

      February 13, 2019

      Features

      Sen. Winter Confident Paid Leave Bill Will Pass…

      February 13, 2019

      Features

      ‘Robot lawyers’ still coming, task efficiency should improve

      February 7, 2019

      Features

      The Business Case for Public Service Holland &…

      February 7, 2019

      Legislature

      Senate Committee Advances Pay Equity Bill

      February 21, 2019

      Legislature

      Sen. Lee Hopes Bill for Court Appearance Reminders…

      February 19, 2019

      Legislature

      House Committee Advances Bill Expanding Sexual Contact Definition…

      February 18, 2019

      Legislature

      Senate Judiciary Committee Kills Bill to Increase State…

      February 12, 2019

  • Business
    • Business of Law

      BCLP Launches Legal Operations Consultancy New focus provides…

      November 27, 2018

      Business of Law

      Lewis Roca Names New Colorado Managing Partner

      November 6, 2018

      Business of Law

      Lobbying Firms Under Microscope for Saudi Work

      November 5, 2018

      Business of Law

      Firmspace Targets Legal Profession

      November 2, 2018

      Business of Law

      Recruiter Salary Survey Finds Money Walks

      October 16, 2018

  • Courts
    • Courts

      10th Circuit Concludes Recreational Use Statute Case A…

      February 21, 2019

      Courts

      Pivotal Condemnation Case Argued at Colorado Supreme Court…

      February 19, 2019

      Courts

      Messner Reeves Sees Slew of Trial Wins

      February 14, 2019

      Courts

      Federal Appellate Court Considers ‘Right to Bail’ Eighth…

      January 31, 2019

      Courts

      Federal Appellate Court Considers ‘Right to Bail’

      January 31, 2019

  • People
    • All Associate Watch Lateral Watch
      Lateral Watch

      Brownstein Adds Shareholder to Litigation Department

      February 21, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Caplan & Earnest Adds One

      February 19, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Foley & Lardner Adds Health Care Partner

      November 27, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Ballard Spahr Adds Two

      November 19, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Ballard Spahr Adds Two

      November 19, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Holland & Hart Adds Four Associates

      November 15, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Stinson Leonard Street Adds to Business Litigation Division

      November 13, 2018

      Associate Watch

      Erise IP Adds Associate

      November 13, 2018

      Lateral Watch

      Brownstein Adds Shareholder to Litigation Department

      February 21, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Caplan & Earnest Adds One

      February 19, 2019

      Lateral Watch

      Foley & Lardner Adds Health Care Partner

      November 27, 2018

      Lateral Watch

      Fred Yarger Rejoins Gibson Dunn

      November 12, 2018

  • Community
    • All Education Events
      Events

      Marijuana Regulators, Enforcers Deliver Insights Cannabis Symposium convenes…

      February 20, 2019

      Events

      Pledge to Diversity Kicks Off Law students mingle…

      February 6, 2019

      Events

      Hetal Doshi Receives Dick Davis Award Annual Dick…

      February 4, 2019

      In The Community

      Corporate Counsel Convene at Crawford Hotel ACC Colorado…

      January 30, 2019

      Education

      Beyond Just an Occupation

      November 12, 2018

      Education

      Pro Bono Week

      October 22, 2018

      Education

      CU Law Launches Human Rights Program

      December 11, 2017

      Education

      Setting the Bar on Law School Admissions

      November 15, 2017

      Events

      Marijuana Regulators, Enforcers Deliver Insights Cannabis Symposium convenes…

      February 20, 2019

      Events

      Pledge to Diversity Kicks Off Law students mingle…

      February 6, 2019

      Events

      Hetal Doshi Receives Dick Davis Award Annual Dick…

      February 4, 2019

      Events

      Ballard Spahr Attorneys Discuss Legal Risks of Public…

      December 7, 2018

  • Opinion
    • Opinion

      Millennials and the Practice of Law: A Changing…

      February 7, 2019

      Opinion

      When Cerebral Palsy is the Result of Medical…

      January 24, 2019

      Opinion

      Expecting the Unexpected

      November 23, 2018

      Opinion

      Surge in Apartment Construction Fuels Condo Conversions

      October 26, 2018

      Opinion

      Restrictive Covenants in Construction Contracts

      October 25, 2018

  • Hearsay
LegislatureNews

Third Time a Charm for “Ban the Box” in Colorado
House committee advances bill limiting criminal history inquiries on first job applications

by Julia Cardi February 5, 2019
written by Julia Cardi February 5, 2019
Third Time a Charm for “Ban the Box” in Colorado House committee advances bill limiting criminal history inquiries on first job applications

Rep. Leslie Herod’s voice rose as she closed out her plea to the House Judiciary Committee to vote to advance the “Colorado Chance to Compete Act.” Following a few hours of testimony, the committee was set to decide whether to advance House Bill 1025, Colorado’s latest attempt to bar employers from asking about criminal history on initial applications. Such laws are known as “ban the box” statutes.

“What we’re doing is rooting for people to be able to come back to society, be productive, get that job, in some cases stay sober, in most cases not re-offend,” Herod said, her passion evident in her voice. “So this isn’t just a bleeding-heart liberal bill or some hashtag. This is real people’s lives.”

The committee advanced House Bill 1025 on an 8-3 vote Jan. 29. It turned out the third time was a charm for the piece of legislation, having failed in Colorado’s Capitol twice before. The last effort was struck down by the Republican-controlled Senate in 2017. A handful of other states such as Massachusetts, Hawaii, Minnesota and California have passed similar legislations.T

Rep. Leslie Herod’s voice rose as she closed out her plea to the House Judiciary Committee to vote to advance the “Colorado Chance to Compete Act.” Following a few hours of testimony, the committee was set to decide whether to advance House Bill 1025, Colorado’s latest attempt to bar employers from asking about criminal history on initial applications. Such laws are known as “ban the box” statutes.

“What we’re doing is rooting for people to be able to come back to society, be productive, get that job, in some cases stay sober, in most cases not re-offend,” Herod said, her passion evident in her voice. “So this isn’t just a bleeding-heart liberal bill or some hashtag. This is real people’s lives.”

The committee advanced House Bill 1025 on an 8-3 vote Jan. 29. It turned out the third time was a charm for the piece of legislation, having failed in Colorado’s Capitol twice before. The last effort was struck down by the Republican-controlled Senate in 2017. A handful of other states such as Massachusetts, Hawaii, Minnesota and California have passed similar legislations.

Rep. Jovan Melton sponsored House Bill 1025 alongside Herod. While the bill prevents employers from asking about applicants’ criminal records on initial applications, it doesn’t affect their ability to do background checks anytime during the hiring process. The bill also prevents employers from advertising or stating on an application that people with criminal records can’t apply. It contains several exceptions, such as for particular positions that require background checks or bar people with certain criminal histories from holding the position.

Supporters of “ban the box” laws tout their effectiveness in reducing recidivism because of the links between employment and a reduced chance of re-offending. Former offenders are more likely to be called back about a job when they don’t have the stigma of a criminal record attached to them from the moment they apply. 

Herod pointed to a study showing how application questions about criminal history disproportionately impact people of color. White applicants with no criminal history were called back 34 percent of the time, compared to 17 percent who did have records. By contrast, black applicants with no criminal history received a call back in 14 percent of instances, compared to 5 percent of black applicants who had criminal histories.

She said Colorado’s criminal records database has more than 1.8 million people, which includes those who have not been convicted and records of some traffic offenses. 

Most of the dissent against the bill came from a few committee members, rather than stakeholder testimony. Their concerns addressed some of House Bill 1025’s practical impacts on employers. 

Rep. Terri Carver had lingering reservations about how broadly the bill defines “employer” and ultimately voted against it. It defines the term as “a person that regularly engages the services of individuals to perform services of any nature.”

Carver said she doesn’t think those who hire people but don’t fit the traditional understanding of an employer, such as churches or individual people who hire caregivers, may not understand it subjects them to labor law. Carver pointed to one of her neighbors, who has multiple sclerosis and uses a caregiver, as an example.

“I can assure you my next-door neighbor, when she is looking at making that decision, doesn’t contemplate that she has entered into Colorado labor law on how she hires somebody to come in and do live-in care.”

Rep. Hugh McKean voted against the bill because of employers’ practical interests in differentiating job applicants from each other, and he said he doesn’t think a detailed conversation about an applicant’s criminal record is likely to happen if employers’ ability to ask about it is limited. But testimony from people with criminal histories during the meeting about the challenges they have run into finding employment seemed to indicate the opposite: Revealing their criminal record before they have had any face time with an employer turns them into a “faceless felon” the employer is immediately wary of.

“What we’re hearing is absent a change in law, they do not get that conversation,” said Rep. Kerry Tipper.

One amendment to the bill addresses the sole testimony against it. It would create an exemption for third-party workers that contract with nursing and assisted living homes who aren’t directly employed by the facilities they work at, but are still required by law to pass a background check for their jobs. Doug Farmer, president of the Colorado Health Care Association and Center for Assisted Living, said earlier during the meeting the group would withdraw its opposition to the bill if such an amendment were put in.

Several business stakeholder groups testified with a neutral position on House Bill 1025. They said they opposed previous versions of Colorado’s “ban the box” law, but decided to take a neutral position after seeing how much legislators had worked to listen to stakeholders and come up with a bill that gets as many groups as possible to find common ground. Rep. Adrienne Benavidez echoed the sentiment just before voting.

“The sponsors should be applauded for getting all of these diverse groups on the same page and to move forward with this policy,” she said. “And we would be remiss in not supporting this bill.”

— Julia Cardi, [email protected]

Ban the BoxLegislature 2019Leslie Herod
0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterGoogle +Pinterest
previous post
Legal Lasso: The Colorado Connection at the Department of Interior
next post
Helsinn SCOTUS Decision

Reprints

If you would like to order a reprint of this article, fill out the request form below and we will be in touch soon. If you prefer a phone call, please include your number.






  • Submit an Article
  • Submit a Verdict
  • Submit an Event to Law Week
  • Take a Survey
  • State Bill Info
  • Subscribe to Print Edition
  • Buy Copies/Reprints
  • Subscribe to Legal Lasso eNews
  • Gold Book Legislative Guide
  • Careers and Internships
  • Advertise
  • About Law Week
  • 2019 Editorial Calendar
  • Hearsay
  • Circuit Media
  • Locus Studios
  • Awards

  • Subscribe to Print Edition
  • Buy Copies/Reprints
  • Subscribe to Legal Lasso eNews
  • Gold Book Legislative Guide
  • Careers and Internships
  • Advertise

About Us

Published by Circuit Media, Law Week Colorado is the state’s only newspaper published specifically for lawyers, law firms, corporate counsel and the judiciary.

  • Submit an Article
  • Submit a Verdict
  • Submit an Event to Law Week
  • Take a Survey
  • State Bill Info

Follow Us

Facebook

© 2018 Law Week Colorado. All rights reserved.


Back To Top